Posted in

She Was Buried Without A Throat | True Crime Documentary

 

It was around 10:00 in the morning of July 30th, 2011. Residents of an upscale apartment complex in Sydney were startled by the sound of a woman screaming. Just seconds later, they watched in horror as a young woman fell from the balcony of the 15th floor. Moments later, her fiance came running out of the building.

 He looked completely shaken. At first, it seemed like nothing more than a tragic accident. But then investigators found a note in the victim’s pocket that had been torn into tiny pieces. After carefully putting it back together, they discovered it contained just one short message. There are surveillance cameras inside and outside the house.

 Just minutes before her death, those cameras had in fact been recording. One of them captured the final moments before the tragedy. The footage shows Lisa trying to leave the apartment while her fiance forcibly drags her back inside. Uh Neighbors later told investigators that almost immediately afterward, they heard desperate screams.

Advertisements

 “Oh my god, please help me. Please God, help me.” Just over a minute passed. Then Lisa Cecilia Harnum fell from the balcony. Her fiance claimed that she had climbed over the railing herself and accidentally lost her footing. But one passerby said he witnessed something completely different. His testimony would eventually become the key reason investigators stopped treating her death as a tragic accident and began investigating it as an intentional murder.

Hey guys. Let me grab you for just a second. I’m really curious where my audience is watching from, so I’d love for you to drop a comment and tell me what city you’re in and what time it is for you right now. Thanks for taking a moment. Go ahead and share that in the comments, and now let’s keep going. Lisa Cecilia Harnum had loved dancing since she was a child.

As a teenager, she devoted herself to ballet. Friends and family knew her as an outgoing, energetic, and confident young woman. In 2005, when Lisa was 24 years old, she wanted to broaden her horizons, travel, and experience more of the world. Having grown up on the outskirts of Toronto, Canada, where summers are short and hot, and winters are long and brutally cold, it wasn’t surprising that she chose sunny Australia.

Advertisements

She originally arrived on a 12-month working visa. Later, she was able to stay longer after landing a job at the Australian Hair and Beauty College in Sydney. The position was a perfect fit because Lisa had always been passionate about fashion, hair styling, and the beauty industry. Even with the distance and the time difference, she remained very close to her family back in Canada.

 She spoke with her mother, Joan, on a regular basis and kept in touch through letters and messages. The Harnum family fully supported her decision to move overseas, as well as her goal of becoming an Australian citizen and making Australia her permanent home. In 2009, Lisa started looking for a new place to live.

 A friend introduced her to a potential roommate named Simon Gittany, who was about 10 years older than she was. Simon worked in the shoe import business, wore expensive suits, and at least on the surface, lived the kind of luxurious lifestyle often associated with young, successful professionals in Sydney. Together with his business partner, he imported mostly shoes from the United States and sold high-end brands online throughout Australia.

Advertisements

At first, Lisa told her mother the arrangement was only temporary. She planned to stay with Simon until she found another place to live. According to Lisa, there was nothing to worry about because she was almost certain Simon wasn’t interested in women at all. Um Lisa moved into Simon’s luxury apartment on the 15th floor of an upscale residential building in downtown Sydney called The Hyde.

 The apartment featured floor-to-ceiling windows that opened onto a spacious balcony overlooking Hyde Park, a roughly 40-acre park in the heart of the city’s business district. Just 2 months after becoming roommates, the two began a romantic relationship. Lisa told her mother that she and Simon got along well. Interestingly though, she never once said that she loved him.

Even so, the relationship continued to grow. As time went on, they became even closer and their relationship grew increasingly serious. In June of 2011, on Lisa’s 30th birthday, Simon proposed to her in front of a large group of guests at a restaurant. He had invited his closest friends and family to be there for the occasion.

>> [laughter] >> In June of 2011, Simon proposed to Lisa on her 30th birthday during a celebration at a restaurant with a large group of guests watching. He had invited his closest friends and family to share the special moment. Grab your purse, your passport, and get out of there right now.

 Less than 24 hours later, officers from the Toronto Police Department knocked on Joan Harnum’s door. They had come to deliver heartbreaking news from Australia. At around 10:00 on the morning of July 30th, 2011, a young Japanese exchange student was walking with his brother to Liverpool Street to catch a bus home. He was waiting at a bus stop beside Hyde Park, directly across from The Hyde, the apartment building where Simon and Lisa lived.

As he stood there, he heard a loud noise that made him look up. Later, he couldn’t say for certain exactly what he had heard. But what he saw next stayed with him forever. A human figure was falling down the side of the building. On one of the balconies above, a shirtless man was leaning over the railing looking down.

Just minutes later, Simon Gittany, still wearing his pajamas, ran out of the building to the spot where his fiance had fallen. Police officers and paramedics arrived within minutes, but the fall had been fatal. Lisa Cecilia Harnum was dead. Her purse was lying beside her body. She was fully dressed except for one shoe, which had most likely come off during the fall.

Investigators found a note in Lisa’s pocket that had been torn into tiny pieces. After carefully putting it back together, they discovered it contained a single message. There are surveillance cameras inside and outside the house. At the time Lisa fell, surveillance cameras inside the apartment were in fact recording.

Advertisements

 The exterior security cameras were also operating and captured what happened immediately after the tragedy. The footage shows Simon, appearing to be in a state of extreme shock, rushing out of the apartment and calling for the elevator before briefly going back inside. By the time he stepped into the hallway again, the elevator had arrived, and he had managed to put on a shirt.

From the moment Lisa fell to the time Simon reached the ground floor, approximately 4 minutes had passed. >> [music] >> Simon explained to investigators how to operate the apartment security system and surveillance cameras. However, he never told them about the hard drive that was believed to contain archived recordings from the cameras inside the apartment.

 By the time investigators learned it existed, the hard drive had already disappeared. Even so, they were still able to recover the most important piece of evidence showing what happened just minutes before Lisa’s fall. A camera pointed at the front door captured a brief but crucial segment of video. The footage shows Lisa trying to leave the apartment before Simon pulls her back inside by force.

 It was recorded approximately 65 to 69 seconds before she fell. It was clear that the couple had been in a heated argument shortly before the tragedy. Simon Gittany did not deny that. Neighbors also told investigators they could hear Lisa screaming from inside their own apartments. According to them, she was yelling, “Help me! Help me! Oh my god, please help me!” One of the neighbors also reported hearing someone pounding loudly on the door of his apartment from the hallway.

 Then everything went silent. Simon told investigators the argument had started after Lisa said she had a secret but refused to tell him what it was. According to Simon, the situation quickly calmed down. He explained that whenever they argued, one of them would usually make a peace offering and then they would sit down and talk things through.

This time, Simon said he went into the kitchen to make Lisa a cup of tea. While he was there, he asked her again about the mysterious secret. According to his account, Lisa suddenly stood up in the living room and ran toward the balcony connected to her bedroom. Simon chased after her. He believed she was only trying to scare him.

He claimed this kind of behavior wasn’t unusual for her. According to Simon, she had previously opened the door of a moving car and threatened to jump out. On another occasion, he said she actually did jump from the vehicle, although it was moving slowly at the time. >> [music] >> After climbing over a treadmill that was sitting on the balcony, Lisa climbed over the railing.

Simon claimed she appeared to shift her weight onto the top of the awning beneath the balcony, mistakenly believing it was level with the balcony floor, but it wasn’t. She slipped. Unable to hold on, Lisa fell. Simon rushed to the edge of the balcony and reached out trying to grab her, but it was already too late.

 He screamed her name in desperation. It’s possible that this was the shout the young exchange student heard from the bus stop below. At first glance, Simon’s version of events seemed believable. Even some of the physical evidence appeared to support his account. But serious questions began to emerge almost immediately.

 For example, why would Lisa climb over the railing while carrying her purse? Crime scene investigators found no fingerprints belonging to Lisa on the glass balcony railing. Instead, they found Simon’s fingerprints. However, some experts pointed out that if Lisa had climbed over the railing while holding her purse and using it against the glass for support, she likely would have left only smudged marks rather than clear fingerprints.

And that was exactly what investigators found. Was Simon’s explanation convincing enough to eliminate suspicion that he had murdered her? The murder charge might never have been filed if not for one crucial witness who saw far more than just the aftermath of the tragedy. Joshua Rathmell was also walking through Hyde Park at around 10:00 that morning when unexplained screams drew his attention to the balcony on the 15th floor of The Hyde.

>> What you saw on that night first if you saw anything? >> It’s my perception without a shirt on carrying what I thought at the time was a black uh suitcase or bit of luggage or several items. Um and it looked to me as though he was unloading them, throwing them off. It was someone holding the black object uh and unloading it almost in a rage.

>> Joshua never actually saw what had hit the ground. Instead, he crossed over to Liverpool Street where a crowd had already gathered around someone who appeared to be receiving CPR. A few minutes later, he saw a man, we now know was Simon Gittany. Simon came running out of the building wearing red striped pajama pants and a white t-shirt.

>> After what seemed like quite a while, definitely maybe 4 minutes, um I would say um a man in a white shirt and red pajama pants uh came out um and and observed the body from a distance for a short while before going uh crouching next to it and speaking to uh the people trying to revive her. >> Joshua worked as an editor for ABC, the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.

After witnessing the incident, he continued with his work day as usual. But later that day, when he saw news reports about Lisa’s death, he realized he had witnessed the very tragedy being reported and contacted the police. His testimony would later become the subject of intense [music] debate. In messages to her mother, Lisa had written about the man who started out as her roommate and eventually became her fiance.

 “I think I’m in love with this man.” At the same time though, she told her mother that he was suffocating her with his constant attention and controlling behavior. >> [music] >> In September of 2010, nearly a year before her death, Lisa wrote, “I miss my family and friends so much. I don’t have a life of my own anymore.” Simon persuaded Lisa to quit her job at the beauty salon.

Later, he convinced her to stop going to a regular gym. Instead, a personal trainer came to the apartment to work with her. Simon also insisted that Lisa, who had always loved fashion in the beauty industry, dress as modestly and plainly as possible. Simple pants or skirts, preferably flat shoes, nothing revealing or attention-grabbing.

He wanted her long hair tied back at all times, and he didn’t allow her to wear makeup, either. After Lisa’s death, her family and friends realized just how isolated she had become. The outgoing, energetic, and confident dancer they once knew had slowly become only a shadow of her former self. Simon Gittany, however, described their relationship very differently.

Yes, they argued. Yes, they made compromises. And despite what he admitted could sometimes be overbearing behavior, he insisted their relationship was filled with love and affection. There is an audio recording from June 10th, 2011, about a month before Lisa’s death. She secretly recorded a late-night conversation with her fiance.

Simon often called her by her middle name, Cecilia. >> I have nothing else to do in my life other than you. That’s it. If I had my family here, you know what? I would spend half of my time with you and half of my time with my family. You know what I mean? I don’t have anybody else. >> You have me. >> So, when I’m by And I’m not trying to make you feel bad, Simon, but it hurts my feelings when you say the things to me.

No, it’s like I’ve never I You know what? I I always wait wait at home for you. I do it like I don’t go anywhere. I don’t do anything without your permission, without asking you, without you being okay with everything. And I don’t do anything other than whatever it is that you tell me to do. It’s like, you know what? Honestly, Simon, sometimes the things you say to me, can you really mean? >> They’re not meant to be mean.

 They’re not meant to be mean. >> Sometimes you can you really mean them? I don’t I don’t do anything intentionally to hurt your feelings. I don’t do anything like that. It’s being with you. Like The only time I ever speak to somebody is >> Did I not stick up for you today? Did I not fight for you? >> and I loved it, but you >> And it’s why it’s cuz I love you, Cecilia.

I might not say it all the time or I might not. You know, you might not think it or feel it or, you know, even though we do have a beautiful relationship. But know that it it is real and that I love you. >> In one of his text messages, Simon wrote to Lisa, “Please don’t let any man talk to you and don’t even look at other men.

Your eyes should be on me and me alone.” During the 6 weeks between the engagement and her death, Lisa began to realize the situation she was in and started looking for a way out of the relationship. She turned to her personal trainer, Lisa Brown, for help. Lisa packed some of her belongings and gave them to her trainer to keep safe until she was ready to collect them.

Then, early on the morning of July 30th, she locked herself in the bathroom and secretly called her mother, arranging for Joan to fly to Sydney. >> Um we didn’t know at all to the extent that, you know, how much he was tracking her. Um I just remember one time when she was home and he kept calling her and just for her comment about, “How does he always know where I am?” >> At the time, Lisa didn’t know for certain, but she likely already suspected that Simon was monitoring every phone call, text message, email,

and even her travel bookings through software he had secretly installed on her computer. Little by little, her privacy was disappearing even if she hadn’t yet realized just how extensive his control had become. There were also hidden surveillance cameras inside the apartment that allowed Simon to keep track of her every move.

 They gave him the ability to know exactly what was happening at home even when he wasn’t there. It appears those were the very cameras mentioned in the note found in Lisa’s pocket. That small piece of paper became yet another clue that helped investigators better understand the circumstances in which she had [music] been living. Through that surveillance, Simon learned that Lisa was planning to leave him.

It didn’t come as a surprise because he already knew about her plans long before she was ready to tell him herself. He knew she’d already given some of her belongings to her personal trainer, a clear sign that she had begun preparing to move out. He knew about her phone conversations with her mother. Even details that should have remained private were known to him.

 He even knew about the airline ticket she had purchased to Canada. According to prosecutors, that is why Simon fully understood that Lisa’s decision to leave him [music] was final. Police charged Simon Gittany with murder and once the initial investigation was complete, the case officially moved into the courtroom.

 He was taken into custody. However, in January of 2012, he was released on bail. Simon maintained his innocence and remained free while preparing for trial with his defense team. It wasn’t until November of 2013, just before the closing arguments, that his bail was revoked. From that point on, he remained in custody until the court delivered its final verdict.

Because cameras were not allowed inside the courtroom, journalists closely watched everyone entering and leaving the courthouse. Every appearance by those involved in the case or by members of their families quickly became headline news. One person who drew particular attention was Simon’s new girlfriend, 23-year-old model Rachel Louise.

Nearly every time she arrived at court, she was surrounded by photographers and reporters. Her striking resemblance to Lisa did not go unnoticed and only fueled even more media interest in the trial. Before long, Rachel herself had become one of the most talked about figures in the entire case. >> Simon is good.

>> Can you breathe? >> Rachel stood by Simon throughout the entire trial. Despite growing public criticism and relentless media attention, she never wavered in her support. She came to court every day, carried signs supporting him, and insisted at every opportunity that he was innocent.

 To outsiders, it looked like unwavering loyalty to a man accused of murder. According to reports, Rachel gave Simon about $85,000 of her own savings to help pay for his legal defense. It was nearly everything she had. She also borrowed another $35,000 from friends to help cover the cost of the trial and his attorneys. Even so, Simon claimed the money had run out and that he could no longer afford a full jury trial.

 Because of the financial hardship he reported, the case proceeded under a different legal process. As a result, the trial was decided by a judge alone. Justice Lucy McCallum presided over the four-week trial, which began on October 21st, 2013. During that time, the court carefully examined witness testimony, expert opinions, and every piece of available evidence.

 The defense argued that Lisa had intended to climb over the balcony railing on her own. That became uh one of the central pillars of their case. They also claimed she had been suffering from depression and suggested that this could explain her actions in the final moments of her life. However, there was very little [music] evidence to support that claim.

The court did not receive enough convincing proof to establish that theory. At the same time, there were still inconsistencies in the prosecution’s case, and those issues became the subject of careful examination throughout the trial. The glass balcony railing stood about 1.2 m high. Simon Gittany was 169 cm tall.

That meant he would have had to lift Lisa above his own shoulder level to throw her over the railing. This question was discussed repeatedly during the proceedings. Lisa weighed only 50 kg. Was Simon physically capable of doing what the prosecution alleged and what the key witness described? That became one of the central questions in the case.

Simon’s brother, Anthony Gittany, even attempted to recreate the incident to demonstrate how unlikely the prosecution’s version was. The defense relied on that demonstration to support its argument. In addition, anyone carrying Lisa onto the balcony would have had to maneuver around a treadmill and a large planter positioned in the path leading to the glass railing.

 Yet, when police arrived, neither of those objects had been moved. That also raised questions about the prosecution’s reconstruction of events. Security footage confirmed that only a few minutes passed between Lisa’s fall and the moment Simon ran out of the apartment. He spent most of that time simply waiting for the elevator. As a result, there was virtually no time to clean up or alter the scene, and the defense pointed to that as another argument in Simon’s favor.

There were also questions about Lisa’s physical condition. The prosecution argued that Simon first rendered her unconscious before throwing her from the balcony. But if that had happened, signs of a struggle would normally have been expected. [music] The absence of such injuries became another point of debate during the trial.

 Neighbors reported hearing screams in the hallway outside the apartment that suddenly stopped. Just over a minute passed between that moment and Lisa’s fall. During that time, she could have lost consciousness. Or the argument could have ended, and the two of them might have tried to calm down, although that possibility also seemed unlikely.

>> [music] >> The autopsy found no injuries other than those caused by the fall itself. There were no clear signs of trauma that would explain a loss of consciousness before the fall. If Lisa had in fact been unconscious, it remained unclear how that could have happened. It was also never explained how she could still have been holding her purse if she had lost consciousness.

>> [music] >> That detail remained unresolved as well. All of this inevitably raised questions about the testimony of the prosecution’s key eyewitness, Joshua Rathmell. Of everyone near the building that morning, Joshua had been standing the farthest away. Yet he was the only witness who claimed to have seen what happened immediately before Lisa fell.

 Everyone else heard the commotion and only saw the aftermath. The Japanese exchange student, who had been much closer to the scene and looked up immediately after hearing the screams, [music] never actually saw the fall itself. Joshua testified that he first heard frantic emotional screaming, which drew his attention to the balcony.

 At first, he assumed a drug user was throwing belongings off the balcony. Then he looked up and saw a shirtless man dropping what initially appeared to be a black travel bag from the 15th floor. Only a moment later did he realize what he had actually witnessed was far more horrifying. During the trial, Joshua agreed with Simon’s defense on one important point.

He acknowledged that he heard the screams >> [music] >> and saw the shirtless man on the balcony almost simultaneously. That detail became one of the key issues when the court evaluated the accuracy of his [music] observations and the reliability of his testimony. We’re talking about a fraction of a second. The only thing I’m certain of is that the scream caught my attention instantly.

 Given the very short amount of time and the considerable distance involved, do you agree that he could have been mistaken in your observations? Absolutely, Joshua replied calmly, acknowledging that such a possibility did exist. Even so, the circumstantial evidence, when viewed as a whole, remained compelling. Piece by piece, [music] the events formed a single coherent picture that according to the prosecution was consistent with the established facts.

The argument had spilled out of the apartment and continued in the hallway about a minute before Lisa’s death. That brief period became one of the most important parts of reconstructing her final moments. [music] By Lisa’s own account, Simon was an extremely controlling and jealous partner. She repeatedly described him as someone who wanted complete control over the relationship.

 Other evidence supported those claims as well, adding to the broader picture of Simon and Lisa’s relationship that the court carefully examined throughout the trial. It also emerged that Simon had a documented history of violence. Um his past included a number of incidents that became part of the court’s review. He was first arrested for assault as a teenager in 1991.

That was only the beginning of a series of criminal incidents that later came to light during the trial. After a dispute with his ex-girlfriend’s employer, Simon returned with about 12 acquaintances and brutally assaulted the man. It became one of the most serious incidents from his early criminal history. A few years later police found stolen property inside his car leading to yet another run-in with law enforcement.

When officers later came to his home after he failed to appear in court, Simon assaulted two detectives. Instead of complying with police, he once again resorted to violence. In his 20s, he was charged with intentionally causing grievous bodily harm to a police officer after biting off part of the officer’s ear.

 That incident became yet another indication that Simon’s violent behavior had been documented long before the events surrounding Lisa Harnum’s case. >> He fell back onto a bed and I landed on top of him. Um that’s when I felt him bite into my left ear. He bit right through and spat the piece out. >> Lisa Harnum had no idea she was living with a man who had previously been sentenced to 2 and 1/2 years in prison.

It was part of his past that as later became clear, she never learned about. Um he never served the full sentence though. His time in custody ended earlier than originally ordered. Simon had carefully concealed his criminal history. He never shared it with the people around him and successfully created an entirely different image of himself.

After convincing the court that he genuinely regretted his past actions and intended to become a Catholic, he was granted permission to travel to France. But those plans didn’t last long. Before long, Simon returned, leaving those ambitions behind, and his life quickly fell back into familiar patterns.

 Later, he was arrested again in connection with a drug supply case. It became yet another chapter in his criminal record. A court in New South Wales found him guilty and sentenced him to 3 years of periodic detention. That added another conviction to his record, one that Lisa also knew nothing about. By the time Lisa moved in with him, Simon was importing women’s shoes and running a website called Shoe Candy.

That business became the foundation of his public image. On the surface, he appeared to be a successful and completely legitimate businessman. To anyone looking from the outside, it seemed as though he had built a stable life and left his past behind for good. While delivering an unprecedented 5-hour judgment, Justice McCallum said Simon Gittany reacted with nothing but rage after discovering that Lisa had secretly moved some of her belongings out of the apartment.

In the court’s view, that discovery became the turning point that led to [music] the tragedy. Justice McCallum found Joshua Rathmell’s testimony to be reliable, even though a defense expert argued that his memory had likely been distorted and reconstructed after the event based on information he learned later.

After considering all of the evidence, the court accepted Joshua’s account. The judge also found Simon’s own testimony unconvincing. In her view, it did not sound like the genuine recollection of someone describing real events. She said he came across as someone performing a role. His testimony felt more like a carefully rehearsed performance than the natural account of a person telling the truth.

Justice McCallum also observed that although Simon’s version fit the physical evidence remarkably well, almost as if every box had been checked, his account lacked the ordinary human details that are typically present in truthful recollections. In her opinion, that unnatural quality seriously undermined the credibility of his explanation.

Uh she also rejected the defense’s claim that Lisa had been prone to suicide or self-harm, finding there was insufficient evidence to support that theory. When the final verdict was delivered, the courtroom fell silent. After years of investigation, it was the moment everyone had been waiting for. The verdict was unequivocal, guilty.

After Simon Gittany was convicted of murder, Rachel Louise could no longer contain her emotions. She stood up in the courtroom and shouted directly at Justice McCallum, “You’re freaking wrong!” She then rushed out of the courtroom in tears. Overcome with emotion, Rachel hurried toward the exit, desperate to get away from the eyes of everyone in the courtroom, as well as the reporters and cameras that continued to follow her every move.

It became one of the most emotional moments of the entire trial involving her. >> I’m going to bed. >> Does anyone have a light on? >> If you could just give me a second. May I have a light on, please? >> Does anyone have a light on? >> have a >> Yeah. >> Before long, Rachel Louise became the target of increasingly harsh criticism from the media, both in Australia and around the world.

Her name appeared more and more often in newspaper headlines, television reports, and news stories, while public attention surrounding her intensified with every new day of the trial. She was heavily criticized for continuing to stand by Simon Gittany despite the murder charges against him. To many people, her loyalty was impossible to understand, making Rachel one of the most controversial figures connected to the case.

During the trial, she regularly stepped outside for cigarette breaks. Every time she walked out of the courthouse, reporters, photographers, and television crews immediately surrounded her, following her every move in hopes of getting a comment or capturing even the slightest reaction on camera. Despite the relentless media pressure and growing public condemnation, Rachel continued to insist that Simon could not have killed Lisa.

She never abandoned that position, even as the criticism directed at her became increasingly intense. The most sympathetic observers believed she was simply young, naive, and unaware of the full reality of what had happened. Others were far less forgiving. They accused Rachel of exploiting Lisa’s tragedy for her own 15 minutes of fame and deliberately encouraging the media attention surrounding her.

Some people even made cruel jokes, saying she should stand beside her boyfriend on the very same balcony. Those remarks reflected just how toxic and unforgiving the public reaction to the case had become. Uh Rachel later sued the Daily Telegraph over three separate articles that she claimed portrayed her as a prostitute, a stripper, a foolish young woman, and someone with loose morals.

 She argued that the publications had seriously damaged her reputation and created a deeply degrading public image of her. By the time Rachel testified in that case in May of 2015, she and Simon were no longer in a relationship. Their romance had ended, although public interest in her role in the story remained strong. Rachel eventually reached a settlement with the Daily Telegraph, but the terms of the agreement were never made public.

Even after that, she continued to insist that Simon was innocent of Lisa’s murder, refusing to change her position despite the court’s verdict and years of public controversy. In the end, Justice McCallum sentenced 40-year-old Simon Gittany to a prison term of between 18 and 26 years for the murder of Lisa Harnum.

 The sentence brought an end to the long legal battle in what had remained one of Australia’s most high-profile criminal cases for several years. >> He’s got a heavy attention from the detectives. >> Do you still think he’s innocent? >> In 2016, Simon lost his appeal. The court found no grounds to overturn the conviction, and the original verdict remained in place.

 It marked another confirmation that the case, which had remained in the public spotlight for years, had reached its final [music] legal resolution. Um Simon will not become eligible for parole until May of 2031. Until then, he is required to continue serving the sentence imposed by the court. Joan Harnum, along with other members of the family, traveled from Toronto to Sydney and remained there throughout the entire trial.

 They attended the hearings, followed every stage of the proceedings closely, and waited for a decision they hoped would bring at least a measure of justice after losing Lisa. After the trial came to an end, Joan shared a few words about the legacy Lisa Cecilia left behind. Those words became a fitting conclusion to her family’s years-long fight for justice and to keep their daughter’s memory alive.

>> We will always mourn the loss of our beautiful Lucy Cecilia and are working towards making her legacy a powerful wake-up call to young women and to parents, siblings, and friends of these young women to be aware of the warning signs of a controlling relationship and take a proactive approach to assisting them.

>> The Lisa Harnum Foundation provides support to individuals and families affected by domestic and family violence, helping those who find themselves in dangerous and difficult [music] situations. The foundation’s work is focused not only on supporting survivors, but also on raising awareness about a problem that often remains hidden from public view.

You can learn more about the foundation, its mission, and its support programs by visiting its official website, which is linked in the description of this video. Despite the court’s verdict, those who continue to believe Simon is innocent often point to the home videos Lisa recorded during the happier periods of their relationship.

 In those recordings, the two of them are smiling, spending time together, and appear to be an ordinary couple deeply in love. That is why Simon’s supporters continue to ask the same question. Do these videos really look like the relationship of two people whose story could have ended in such a brutal murder? For them, those recordings remain one of the strongest arguments in a case that continues to spark debate even today.

>> Let me see the fingers. Let’s do the close-up on the face. Look at all the Look at all the stuff all over there. >> In the slime. >> Oh. Moving right along.

 

Disclaimer : This content may be created by AI for entertainment purposes. Any resemblance to real persons, events, or places is coincidental.

Advertisements